In his role as Arnold Jackson the 1970s and '80s television series "Diff'rent Strokes," child actor Gary Coleman injected pop culture with an indignantly expressed question: "What you talkin' 'bout?"
That catchphrase retains enduring value in the context of nonsensical utterances in contemporary advertising, bureaucratic statements and political pronouncements. People often don't clearly express what they mean.
For example, a radio commercial boasted, "Remember, that's Downtown Ford, where no one can save you more."
Gee, if no one at Downtown Ford can save you more, you might consider shopping elsewhere for a better price.
When Doug Ose was campaigning for re-election to Congress, he declared, "In Congress, I voted to cut taxes 80 times."
Some voters may have thought, "Wow! Legislation that will cut taxes 80 times! I hope it passes."
Ose meant to say, of course, that he had voted 80 times to cut taxes but that's not what he said.
A television news reporter who was interviewing a public health official asked, "Will avoiding crowds further stop the spread of the H1N1 flu?"
Cessation is not measurable by degrees; it's absolute. Something either is stopped or it isn't; it can't be "further stopped." The reporter should have said "further slow" or better yet "curtail" the spread of H1N1.
In an article about the importance of maintaining proper pH in athletic field turf and golf greens, a university agricultural researcher wrote, "More than likely your soil needs lime."
The adjective "likely" indicates a high probability of occurring. If something is "more than likely," then it's doubtless, assured, certain. Your soil needs lime. Period.
"Last summer I had the opportunity to meet Rudy Giuliani," Fred said during the luncheon.
Several people wondered whether or not Fred acted on that opportunity. Fred didn't say that he met Guiliani but merely that he had the opportunity to do so.
A news account puzzlingly began, "A rocket launched by a private company crashed in the New Mexico desert this week before it achieved orbit."
So after crashing, it achieved orbit? What you talkin' 'bout?
The reporter should have written, "A rocket launched by a private company failed in its attempt to achieve orbit and crashed in the New Mexico desert this week."
Amazed by the capabilities of a friend's mobile phone, Wilma mused, "What won't they think of next?
Wilma, don't you mean "what will they think of next?" (Whoever they are.)
In a recurrent television commercial for a salad dressing, an announcer says, "There's a place called Hidden Valley where kids not only eat their vegetables, they can't get enough."
That sounds like the supply of vegetables there is insufficient to meet the needs of those apparently undernourished children.
The script probably should have said, "In a place called Hidden Valley, even after kids finish eating all of their vegetables, they're always ready for more."
A photo caption in the automotive section of a newspaper read, "Toyota Prius consumes 48 mpg in the city, and 45 mpg on the highway."
The abbreviation "mpg," of course, stands for "miles per gallon." The Prius doesn't consume miles; the caption should have said that the Prius attains 48 mpg.
"We have a 13-year-old boy missing in Fremont," a radio news crew announced.
Not true. If the crew members did have the boy, he wouldn't be missing.
A competing station reported, "a 13-year-old boy has turned up missing."
No, he hasn't turned up. He's missing.
A city's announcement about a new administrative appointment declared, "As deputy mayor, he will earn $213,000 a year."
That cannot be said with certainty yet. The verb "earn" carries an implication of proof of worthiness or deserving of compensation as a result of meritorious job performance. The city will pay him a salary of $213,000 per year an amount that he may not necessarily earn.
University police officers discovered a 9 mm gun, two loaded magazines and bullets in a metal box in the dormitory room of a student, who eluded capture. The university president told news reporters, "the student's motives are unknown."
That's improbable. At least one person the student himself ‚ knows the motives. The president should have said, "neither university police nor administrators have learned the student's motives."
Pauline identified herself as the "executive director of a nonprofit."
Her friend Roy, who works for a commercial business, does not describe his employer as a "profit"; he says he works for a "profit-making enterprise." Accordingly, Pauline's employer is a nonprofit organization.
An Associated Press news story published in 2008 described a report analyzing impending problems in delivery of health care for the aging "baby boomer" population. A committee of the Institute of Medicine, an arm of the National Academy of Sciences, prepared the report. Here is how the article summarized four key points of the report:
There aren't enough specialists in geriatric medicine.
Insufficient training is available.
The specialists who do exist are underpaid.
Medicare fails to provide for team care that many elderly patients need.
Take a look at that second bullet point: "insufficient training is available." That sounds like an appealing choice for a struggling student. Why bother taking the regular, difficult training program when "insufficient training is available"?
The bullet item, of course, was poorly composed. It should have read:
Training programs cannot accommodate the large number of geriatricians needed.
As Pete offered his assessment of a problem, Luisa squinted her eyes, then raised her forefinger.
"Pete, I don't know that I would say that, " Luisa said.
Pete and other committee members thought to themselves, "Gee, Luisa, you sound uncertain about whether or not you disagree. So you don't know that you would say that. Well then, what you talkin' 'bout?"
She would have made her position clear if she had simply said, "I disagree."
The Springfield school board announced that a middle school principal had been "placed on paid administrative leave pending an investigation into charges that he had been carrying a concealed weapon on school grounds. Police escorted him off campus without incident."
The phrase "paid administrative leave" is illogical. He's not administering anything now, because he's on leave from the school. He was suspended from duty, and will be paid during his absence.
In a story about the disappearance of a child, a news reporter declared, "Police have not issued an Amber Alert because there is no evidence that the girl was abducted."
That's inaccurate; the reporter cannot say with certainty that such evidence does not exist. The reporter should have written: "... because law enforcement officers have not discovered any evidence indicating that the girl was abducted."
An actor playing Eric, a suspect in a dramatic presentation, blurted, "But, Abby is the last person I'd want to hurt."
That sounds like Eric has a waiting list of other people he intends to hurt first, before moving on to Abby.
A television news reporter, dispatched to cover a fire at a small business, declared, "Fire inspectors don't believe the building had fire sprinklers."
That statement suggests that perhaps fire inspectors were disputing someone's contention that the building had fire sprinklers, but there was no such controversy. The reporter should have said, "Fire inspectors believe that the building lacked fire sprinklers."
A sign in a hospital reception room said, "The laboratory waiting area was made possible through the generosity of the Accounting Firm of Nichols, Moola and Dinero."
Well, no. Design and construction of the space would have remained a possibility with or without the involvement of the accounting firm. The sign probably should have read, "The Accounting Firm of Nichols, Moola and Dinero generously donated funds to furnish and decorate the laboratory waiting area."
Each time you're writing or preparing to speak before an audience, think of Arnold Jackson. Make sure none of your statements would provoke him to ask, "What you talkin' 'bout?"